An arrow that will not budge can interrupt an enjoyable practice session. A dedicated arrow puller provides a gripping surface around the shaft, while some designs add mechanical assistance for more difficult removal.
The best choice depends on your hand size, arrow diameter, and target. A flexible rubber puller may suit routine retrieval, while a lever-assisted model serves a different purpose.
These picks are based on manufacturer descriptions and published features, rather than hands-on comparative testing. Amazon links below are searches; confirm the exact model, seller, and availability before ordering.
Quick Comparison
Table of Contents
| Product | Main reason to consider it | Check before buying |
|---|---|---|
| LimbSaver Arrow Puller | Contoured grip with lanyard | Hand fit and shaft grip |
| AAE Gorilla Grip | Larger natural-rubber body | Whether the grip feels too bulky |
| OMP Flex-Pull | Soft, flexible palm-fitting design | Included clip or retractor |
| Allen K’Netix Arrow Puller | molded handle | accommodating different arrow-shaft diameters. |
| Hamskea AroJac | Lever-assisted extraction | Shaft compatibility and model version |
1. LimbSaver Arrow Puller — Best for a Contoured Everyday Grip
The LimbSaver Arrow Puller is a sensible starting point if you want a straightforward accessory for regular target practice.
LimbSaver describes a custom handle shape that molds around the shaft when squeezed, grippy material intended to resist slipping, and an included lanyard. The company markets it for different arrow diameters and offers several colors. limbsaver.com
Its contoured shape is the main reason to compare it with a flat grip pad. Comfort will depend on your hand size and how fully you can close the puller around your arrow.
Why consider it:
- Contoured handle design.
- Included carrying lanyard.
- Bright color options.
Check before buying: Confirm that it grips your actual shaft diameter securely. Broad compatibility claims do not guarantee easy removal from every target.
Amazon link: Amazon.com : Limbsaver Arrow Puller w/Lanyard – OD Green : Sports & Outdoors
2. AAE Gorilla Grip Arrow Puller — Best for a Larger Rubber Grip
The AAE Gorilla Grip is worth comparing if a small puller feels difficult to hold.
AAE specifies solid natural-rubber construction and a large-diameter design. Its official listing offers Standard and Elite versions and describes compatibility with different arrow sizes. Arizona Archery Enterprises Inc.
The larger body gives this model a clear point of difference. However, you still need to close your hand comfortably and maintain a secure hold.
Why consider it:
- Solid natural-rubber construction.
- Large-diameter gripping body.
- Standard and Elite versions.
Check before buying: Compare the exact version and product photos. If possible, try the grip before ordering, especially if you have smaller hands.
3. October Mountain Products Flex-Pull — Best for a Soft, Flexible Design
The October Mountain Products Flex-Pull is a practical option for archers who prefer a flexible accessory that fits into the palm.
OMP describes lightweight, flexible material and includes a quiver or belt clip. The manufacturer positions it for target and 3D archery and markets it for a range of shaft sizes. octobermountainproducts.com
The clip is useful if you want the puller accessible between ends instead of searching through your bow case.
Why consider it:
- Soft, flexible construction.
- Palm-fitting design.
- Included quiver or belt clip.
Check before buying: Read the accessory list carefully. A standard Flex-Pull and a version bundled with a retractor may have different contents.
4. Allen K’Netix Arrow Puller — Best for Convenient Clip-On Carrying
The Allen K’Netix Arrow Puller is a practical alternative if you want a simple grip accessory that attaches to your range equipment.
Allen specifies soft rubber construction, a molded handle, and a snap clip for attaching the puller to a belt, quiver, or D-ring. The manufacturer describes it as accommodating different arrow-shaft diameters. byallen.com
The carrying clip helps keep it accessible between shooting ends. Its molded shape is worth comparing with your hand size, particularly if you wear gloves during practice.
Why consider it:
- Soft rubber gripping surface.
- Molded handle.
- Snap clip for convenient carrying.
Check before buying: Confirm the listing is for the Allen K’Netix Arrow Puller, model 151. Check that you can close the grip securely around your shaft; compatibility claims do not guarantee easy removal from every target.
5. Hamskea AroJac — Best for Lever-Assisted Removal
The Hamskea AroJac differs from the simple rubber pullers above. It grips the shaft with jaws and uses a lever to move the arrow away from the target in successive strokes.
Hamskea designed it for difficult removal from 3D targets. Its current product description identifies TPV gripping jaws and a pivoting head in the updated design. Hamskeaarchery
This makes it worth investigating when grip assistance alone is insufficient. It requires more attention to setup and operation than a squeeze-style rubber puller.
Why consider it:
- Lever-assisted extraction.
- Shaft-gripping jaws.
- Updated pivoting-head design.
Check before buying: Confirm the version pictured, shaft compatibility, and suitability for your target. Read the operating instructions before use; older retailer listings may show a previous design.
Amazon link: Amazon.com : Hamskea Archery Solutions AroJac (103001) : Sports & Outdoors
How to Choose an Arrow Puller
Match the Grip to Your Hand
Match the Grip to Your HandChoose a shape you can close securely around the shaft. Compare thickness and flexibility as well as size. If you wear gloves during practice, consider how they affect your grip.
Check Your Actual Shaft Diameter
Use your arrow’s outside diameter when checking puller compatibility. Inside diameter and spine rating describe different characteristics.
If a manufacturer does not publish a compatible diameter range, ask about your exact arrow model—particularly for unusually thin or large shafts.
Distinguish Grip From Mechanical Assistance
Distinguish Grip From Mechanical AssistanceLimbSaver, Gorilla Grip, Flex-Pull, and Grasper primarily provide a different surface for your hand to hold. The AroJac adds a lever mechanism.
Slipping hands and repeatedly immovable arrows may require different solutions, so identify the problem before choosing.
Consider Carrying and Maintenance
Look at the included clip, lanyard, or cord and decide where you will keep the puller. For a mechanical model, also check replacement gripping parts and access to current instructions.
Use Good Technique Alongside the Puller
Wait until retrieval is permitted and keep people clear of the arrow’s withdrawal path. Grip close to the target face and apply controlled force in line with the shaft, keeping your body out of that path. Avoid sideways bending or sudden yanking. morrelltargets.com
If an arrow will not move with the correct method, stop and ask range staff for help. Follow the target’s instructions, especially when using broadheads.
After removal, inspect the shaft and components according to the arrow manufacturer’s guidance. Successful removal does not establish that an arrow is safe to shoot; suspected damage requires taking it out of use.
Frequently Asked Questions
Will an arrow puller remove every stuck arrow?
No. Tool fit, target material, penetration, and shaft condition affect the result. Treat easy-removal claims as product descriptions rather than guarantees.
Can one puller work with different arrows?
Several manufacturers describe broad diameter compatibility. Check your shafts and confirm that the puller holds them securely.
Should I choose rubber or lever-assisted?
A rubber puller is a reasonable first comparison for routine retrieval when your hands slip. A lever-assisted model deserves consideration for persistent extraction problems.
