Broadhead practice can wear out the center of an archery target while much of its surrounding body remains usable. Choosing a target with a replaceable shooting core gives you a way to renew that worn area without replacing the entire target.
However, a removable core is only one part of the buying decision. You also need to check broadhead compatibility, arrow-speed restrictions, approved shooting faces, and the availability of replacement parts.
These five picks include block targets, larger technical targets, and deer-shaped targets. Their recommendations are based on published product information, rather than hands-on durability testing.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.
The Amazon links below are product searches. Confirm the exact model and package contents, and replace them with your own Amazon Associates links before publication.
Quick Comparison: The 5 Products
Table of Contents
| Product | Recommended use | Replaceable component | Important consideration |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rinehart RhinoBlock XL | General broadhead practice | RhinoBlock/XL insert | Follow designated broadhead-face instructions |
| Morrell Center Punch 24 With High Roller | Practice with separately documented speed zones | High Roller center insert | Center and surround have different ratings |
| Delta McKenzie Predator 24 Technical | Larger technical target setup | Predator removable core | Confirm exact-model specifications |
| Morrell Transformer Buck | Modular 3D practice | Detachable shooting midsection | Compare midsection replacement costs |
| Rinehart Signature Broadhead Buck | Deer-shaped shot-placement practice | Replaceable shooting core | Verify the correct replacement insert |
1. Rinehart RhinoBlock XL — Best Overall
The Rinehart RhinoBlock XL is a useful starting point for archers who want a conventional block target with a replaceable shooting insert.
Rinehart lists its dimensions as 18 inches high × 18 inches wide × 13 inches deep. Its product description specifies a replaceable self-healing foam insert, and the manufacturer separately lists an insert for both the RhinoBlock and RhinoBlock XL. www.rinehart3d.com
That replacement system is its main attraction. When the insert becomes worn, you can evaluate whether replacing it will restore the target’s useful shooting area while retaining the surrounding body.
Pay attention to the shooting faces. Rogers Sporting Goods identifies two broadhead sides on the XL. Follow the supplied instructions rather than assuming all six faces have identical approved uses. rogerssportinggoods.com
The block format is worth comparing if you want one target for a regular backyard setup and occasional transport. Before ordering, check its weight, handling requirements, and compatibility with your equipment.
Advantages: Replaceable insert, block format, and an 18-inch face.
Considerations: Confirm broadhead faces and equipment limits. Replacing the core does not repair damage elsewhere.
Best for: Buyers wanting a straightforward replaceable-insert block target.
Amazon links:
Amazon.com: Rinehart RhinoBlock XL Target, 6-Sided, Broadhead Compatible : Sports & Outdoors
2. Morrell Center Punch 24 With High Roller — Best for a Documented High-Speed Center
The Morrell Center Punch 24 With High Roller combines a replaceable center insert with a larger surrounding foam body.
Morrell lists overall dimensions of 24 × 13 × 24 inches and compatibility with field points and broadheads. Its most important specification is the difference between the two speed ratings: the High Roller insert is rated to 450 FPS, while the surrounding fused-layer foam is rated to 365 FPS. www.morrelltargets.com
Those ratings must remain separate when comparing this target with your setup. The higher rating applies to the insert, not the entire face. If your arrows exceed the surrounding foam’s rating, an off-center shot becomes an important compatibility concern.
Ask Morrell whether the complete arrangement suits your equipment and expected accuracy before buying.
Check the listing title and package contents carefully. A Center Punch sold without the High Roller insert is a different purchase from the complete combination reviewed here. www.morrelltargets.com
Advantages: Replaceable center and clearly differentiated center/surround ratings.
Considerations: Respect both ratings and verify that the insert is included.
Best for: Archers comparing a target with a documented higher-rated center.
Amazon links:
3. Delta McKenzie Predator 24 Technical — Best Larger Technical Target Option
The Delta McKenzie Predator 24 Technical is worth comparing if you want a larger target format with a removable shooting core.
Delta McKenzie lists the complete target and separately offers a Predator Series Removable Core, establishing a replacement option for the product family. Confirm the core’s exact fit before ordering. dmtargets.com
SCHEELS describes this specific target as compatible with broadheads and field points and rated up to 450 FPS. Delta McKenzie’s current product page uses broader series-level speed wording, so verify the supplied model instructions before relying on the retailer’s figure for your setup. www.scheels.com
A larger format may suit a mostly stationary practice area, particularly when you find compact targets restrictive. Measure the space needed for storage, transport, and secure positioning before choosing it.
Also distinguish listings for the complete target from listings for the removable core alone.
Advantages: Larger technical format and a separately listed replacement core.
Considerations: Verify exact-model ratings, approved shooting areas, and core compatibility.
Best for: Buyers planning a larger, mostly stationary target setup.
Amazon links:
Amazon.com : Delta McKenzie Crossbow MAX SPEEDBAG, Black (79026) : Sports & Outdoors
4. Morrell Transformer Buck — Best Modular 3D Target
The Morrell Transformer Buck uses a modular shooting section rather than a small central replacement insert.
Morrell describes a High Roller foam shooting core, vitals and scoring rings, a rotating head, and a detachable section that can function as a standalone target. The manufacturer also separately lists a Transformer Buck Mid Section. www.morrelltargets.com
This arrangement offers a practical choice between a complete deer-shaped setup and the detached shooting section. It deserves consideration if that flexibility matches your practice routine.
Replacement costs require a different comparison here. A complete midsection is a larger component than a small insert, so check its delivered price before deciding whether the modular design offers good value for you.
Morrell’s broad compatibility slogan should not replace equipment-specific instructions. Confirm approval for your broadhead type, arrow speed, and intended shooting areas.
Advantages: Detachable standalone shooting section and separately listed midsection.
Considerations: Compare replacement costs and check assembly and equipment requirements.
Best for: Archers wanting a modular deer target with a detachable shooting section.
Amazon links:
Amazon.com : Morrell Targets Transformer Buck 3D Archery Target, Brown : Sports & Outdoors
5. Rinehart Signature Broadhead Buck — Best for Deer-Shaped Practice
The Rinehart Signature Broadhead Buck is a practical option for buyers who prefer a deer-shaped target with a replaceable shooting core.
Rinehart describes self-healing foam, weather-resistant construction, and two different presentations: a realistic whitetail side and a vital-outline side. Its product page explicitly identifies the core as replaceable. www.rinehart3d.com
This format provides a different aiming experience from the dots on a block target. It can suit deer-shaped shot-placement practice, provided you follow the target’s approved shooting areas and equipment limits.
Replacement compatibility deserves particular attention. Rinehart sells several deer targets, and a similarly named buck insert should not be assumed to fit this model. Record the exact target name and confirm the replacement part number with the manufacturer or seller.
Consider the space needed to position, stabilize, and store the complete target as well as the cost of replacing its core.
Advantages: Deer shape, vital-outline presentation, and replaceable core.
Considerations: Verify insert fit, equipment approval, and installation requirements.
Best for: Bowhunters prioritizing deer-shaped broadhead practice.
Amazon links:
How to Choose the Right Target
Check Compatibility Before Durability Claims
Begin with your broadheads and arrows. Confirm whether the target approves fixed blades, mechanical broadheads, or both, along with any restrictions on arrow diameter, outserts, and speed.
Identify the approved shooting areas. A replaceable core does not automatically make every face or surrounding section suitable for broadheads.
Find the Replacement Part Before Buying
Locate the correct insert or shooting section while comparing complete targets. Record its compatibility, delivered price, availability, and installation requirements.
For an older target, confirm that current replacement parts still fit. A removable core is useful only when a suitable replacement remains obtainable.
Compare the Full Ownership Cost
Consider the target price, replacement-part cost, shipping, and any required support equipment.
A more expensive target is not automatically cheaper over time. The value depends on how much you practice, how quickly the shooting area wears, and whether the remaining body stays usable.
Match the Format to Your Space
A block target may be easier to fit into storage, while a deer-shaped target provides a different practice experience.
Measure the available area and think through setup and transport. Include the stand, anchoring equipment, and backstop when planning the complete arrangement.
Maintenance and Safe Practice
Spread shots across approved aiming areas rather than repeatedly using one tiny spot. Rotate or reverse an insert only when the manufacturer permits it.
Inspect core seating, surrounding material, and stopping performance regularly. Unusually deep penetration, loose components, or inconsistent stopping performance require assessment before further shooting.
Follow the target’s storage instructions, remove arrows before transport, and secure sharp broadheads in protective storage.
Choose an approved shooting location with a suitable backstop and clear space behind and beside the target. The range arrangement must account for misses and pass-throughs. Stop all shooting before anyone approaches to retrieve arrows.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does replacing the core restore the whole target?
No. It renews the replaceable shooting area. Damage to the surrounding body, supports, or other components still needs attention.
Are self-healing targets wear-proof?
No. The term describes foam behavior, not immunity to damage. Continue inspecting the target and follow its care instructions.
Can I use a universal replacement insert?
Do not assume so. Match the exact dimensions, shape, retention method, and model compatibility.
Can these targets handle crossbows?
Only when the exact model and shooting zone are approved for your crossbow, bolts, broadheads, and speed.
