Each has its own strength and weaknesses as a target, and each is better than the other in certain situations. Thus, the real challenge is to know what will match your needs and preferences.
Bag vs Block Archery Target Dilemma?
Are you facing the bag vs. block archery target dilemma? Remember that when you are buying a target it should be durable so it can last a long time. This will allow you to get the most out of what you have invested in your target.
It must be resistant in some way to arrow penetration too. This may seem contradictory since what you want is a target that welcomes arrows. However, if you really want an effective archery practice target, you would want it to behave like how it would in a real setting such as when hunting.
Normally the animal would resist the arrow upon impact. Thus, your target should also resist an arrow like an animal for you to know how to effectively hunt a prey. Additionally, your target must withstand numerous shots in the same spot.
Now, a target should have some resistance to arrows. But if there is one aspect where it should be arrow-friendly, that is when you are removing the arrow. No matter how deeply buried it is, a good target should allow easy removal. You shouldn’t have to struggle in any way just to take the arrow out since this may bend the arrow out of shape.
In addition, you must consider what kind of bow and arrow you are using since there are targets that work great with a broadhead arrow but fail miserably with a crossbow. Thus, you should invest in a target that suits the kind of bow and arrow you use for target practice.
After determining all of those things, it is now time to take a look at the two main types of archery targets: bag and block.
Bag vs. Block Archery Target
These targets work great with target points instead of arrows. This type is filled with fibrous material, enabling it to slow down and halt a flying arrow easily. A bag target is also considered the easiest target for removing arrows upon penetration.
To make sure that it does not move when in use it needs to be heavy and dense. Therefore, it is a good idea to check its weight before purchasing it. This is because some manufacturers do not really fill the bag target up to the maximum level because they want to ship lighter ones.
Another thing to consider is where to store a bag target. You need to keep it somewhere inside to prevent it from getting wet in the rain. It is highly recommended that you store a bag target in a dry area to ensure its longevity.
In addition, do not use broadheads because they tend to get stuck and rip through the target entirely. When this happens it is not only the target that is affected, the arrow also gets damaged.
Unlike the bag target, a foam block target can work well with broadhead arrows. It can withstand being penetrated by a broadhead arrow. Since a broadhead is fitted with razor sharp blades, a bag target will not last very long.
A block target can also accommodate field points. There are various styles, sizes, and designs available for a block target, but they are all filled with dense foam inside. This foam slows down the velocity of the arrow in motion, trapping it inside the target. Also, the foam prevents full target penetration.
What happens when you shoot an arrow at this type of target is that it pinches the arrowhead and shaft in the material. It relies on friction to slow down the movement of the arrow instead of stopping the motion of the arrow through force.
This target is quite sturdy, lasting a good long time and is affordable too. Since it is light and easy to carry around if ever you need to move it from one practice range to another. However, one disadvantage is that it is kind of hard to remove arrows because of the deep penetration.